Yah, I kind of went through this last week
. I bought 17x9 rims and had 2 nitto 275/40/zr17's in the back and 2 extremo 275/45/zr17's in the front and they didnt cover the lip.
So I sold the 2 nittos and am still trying to sell the extremos, but I bought 4 new 275/40/zr17 sumimotos and man are they nice. But with the wider tires you can tell how different the car handels / steers vs the original skinnies.