I feel your pain. I went through the same thing. You'll get advice on just about every Axleback available and everyone like theirs the best. And they all are. It depends on everyone's individual taste.
I ended up with FRPP Quad Tip Mufflers and Rear Valance for the following reasons: They are louder than stock but not obnoxious. I don't want too loud but I want sound and they give you a nice low muscle car rumble/growl plus an aggressive sound while accelerating and almost no drone while cruising. Personally, I don't like "raspy". On top of that, being quad tip, can't beat the look! Of course, they cost more and require the rear bumper to be modified to accommodate the new valance, but this is very easy to do as the stock bumper is already marked where it needs to be cut. I used an electric jig saw but it can easily be cut with a hand saw. I figured it's worth the extra cost to also get an awesome look, besides the sound.
I also listened to all sound bites available on YouTube before making my choice.
2014 GT Premium, Custom Painted, 401A, MGW, Brembo, Steeda CAI & 93 Tune
Steeda Sports, HD Mount Koni STR.T BMR Rod/Poly adj. LCA & Relos, PHB & Bracket
Forgestar Custom Painted CF10 19x9+35 & 19x11+42 Roush Grilles & Chin Splitter
FRPP Quad Axleback 3dCarbon GT500 Spoiler MMD Window Louvers SHR Fuel Door JLT Oil Sep.